A Deep Dive Into Agency Utilization — Level x ProHQ

Level Agencies - Finances Ops - 15 min read (because it really is a deep dive!)

A thriving agency full of happy, properly deployed employees, housed in a colorblocked, graphic office space.

No matter what your finances look like, utilization can teach every agency something new about their business.

Agencies can be skittish about measuring utilization. For so many, efforts to understand it have frankly not been implemented well. Goals get handed down from on high to creative staff. Teams push back by not tracking time accurately, or at all. Supervisors double down. The whole experience can feel controlling and punitive.

That’s a shame, because utilization measurement should produce the exact opposite outcome. We’ve worked with agencies of many shapes and sizes, and we can say with confidence that the happiest, most profitable among them use utilization metrics to set clear boundaries around creative work, protecting staff from burnout and keeping margins healthy. These teams also use utilization data to scope and price projects appropriately, keep team members engaged, take on new, value-driving projects, and even reconsider core ICPs. Put in place effectively, utilization is a massive difference-maker for agencies.

This conversation with Level CFOs Sarah Jordan and Jim Milligan, who is also founder and CEO of our partner, ProHQ, helps agency leads do just that. Facilitated by our own resident creative, Kate Greulich, who has spent years in agencies herself, the discussion focuses on "how to set the table," as Jim puts it, for introducing utilization in your organization.

The key takeaway: no matter what your financials look like, utilization can teach you something new about how your business works, in ways that directly impact margin and long-term resilience.

Read on to learn: 

  • What utilization rates can tell you about your business that your financials can't

  • Four utilization metrics that can help your agency get strategic about time use

  • How to set the table for utilization awareness without overburdening teams and prompting push-back

  • How to get started, so that your agency can start to see meaningful utilization data in the next 90 days

What can your utilization rate tell you about your agency that doesn't necessarily show up in the P&L?

JIM: I love that question and will get into it, but I’d be remiss not to start by reminding us that one crucial upstream activity informs utilization metrics: time-tracking.

Agencies resist time-tracking for many reasons (I hope we can dispel some of the fear here), but diligent time-tracking unlocks all the benefits of understanding utilization. It also informs project management, scoping, and pricing, which directly impact margin. Time-tracking connects the dots between people and profitability: it’s a non-negotiable in agency finance.

On the question of what utilization can tell an agency about its business: as we know, revenue and the P&L tell the financial story, but not the drivers of the business itself. They don’t pinpoint the activities that lead to revenue, profit, and loss. A business looking only at financials is missing what makes it tick.

In contrast, utilization tells us about an agency’s goals and strategies. Even just setting a utilization target is a strategic choice that informs how agencies build teams, structure resources, and invest in training and development. It describes the agency’s day-in, day-out work, and how it does and doesn’t relate to the strategic plan. So it’s not about being as efficient as possible, but about defining what work drives the business forward.

SARAH: I'll offer two examples. 

One: Utilization can reveal a resource bottleneck masked by the total project. A project can finish on time and on budget, hitting its revenue and P&L numbers, yet those numbers say nothing about an engineering team at risk of being overburdened.

Two: Utilization is especially helpful when new project opportunities come in, because you can easily know, without question, whether you have the hours and staff available or need to contract out some labor. That facilitates quick responses to RFPs and proposals, which is critical to winning work.

JIM: Right. To take a step back: people often miss that utilization is in service to everybody in the company. It’s not meant to be bureaucratic, punitive micromanagement. It’s about identifying resource gaps so no one has to raise their hand and say, “I’m too busy, you’re burning me out.” The organization should see that and address it. Managers should look out for people who are too busy, or will be too busy to take on future work.

The best companies don’t just talk about utilization as a minimum—they use maximums too. It’s how agency leaders make good on promises to protect their teams’ creativity and well-being.

How should an agency think about utilization rates across the business? With the caveat that every agency is different, can you tell us more about what good utilization looks like for different roles? 

JIM: People often think of utilization as one number—an overall company rate—but it has many components. Client utilization, or time spent on client work, is the starting point, but under that, teams should track billable projects against nonbillable, client-related admin. Nonbillable business development should also be tracked. Those four numbers tell you more about time use: are you spending enough time on client appreciation? On business development? More time with certain clients over others? They help you assign time in ways that are right for you, beyond “our goal is 70% utilization company-wide.”

I’d also tell every agency to know their own utilization math. How, exactly, do you calculate it? Do you base it on 2080 hours for the year (52 weeks * 40 hours), or something less (such as 1840 hours, assuming 30 days of PTO and holidays)? Do you offer unlimited PTO? If so, how do you factor that into your utilization calculation and target? 

SARAH: I think the answer starts with leadership’s vision for culture. An employee-owned team, for example, will need to reserve more time for business development among its creatives, or for L&D, than another agency might. A team like that will never be 70% billable. That’s okay: it reflects the agency’s unique culture and brand values.

JIM: Culture is how you set targets across these categories of billable hours. You also define utilization by thinking through how you structure roles. I don’t often see agencies set these measures at the outset, but it’s worth deciding how billable you want leaders, managers, and staff to be. Typically, you want a pyramid approach, where senior people are least utilized to allow for management and training of staff, and staff get the most hands-on client time. Staff are more profitable, and they also learn the skill and judgment that make them good managers down the road.

Let's talk about non-billable hours. What uses of non-billable work are worth protecting? How can agency leads prioritize non-billable work to strategically add value to the business?

KATE: I ask because for so many early-stage agencies, the objective is just to get clients in and get to work. But when they’re ready to grow, there’s a learning curve in making time and space for marketing and biz dev. That might mean getting the founder out of day-to-day creative work to focus on biz dev, or finding a biz dev team to take that work on. Maybe it's about taking the time to build a product that you can either sell or use to be more efficient. Regardless, it feels risky when you're in that growth moment. 

SARAH: I think there are three considerations here. One, very tactical: nonbillable work includes writing scopes, sending invoices, and sending out contracts. This work isn’t going away, so it’s worth economizing. Use templates you can quickly customize, and use your systems to keep it standardized. It’s a bit of a no-brainer, but I still see teams reinventing the wheel with proposals all the time.

Two: if you work in the public sector at all, biz dev, contracting, and client management will all be bespoke. That will make your utilization look different, because you don’t have a choice: public sector contracts involve different levels of follow-up and customization.

Three: think about what makes your billable work better and is worth investing in over time. If that’s more time off, more L&D, or more nonbillable client management, whatever it is, commit to it in setting utilization targets.

JIM: I agree that those are categories agencies need to protect. A lot of companies struggle to do so because they don't give themselves flexibility when setting goals. But routinely revisiting your assumptions around utilization is important. 

I’d recommend that every agency learn to look at utilization longitudinally, rather than month by month or week by week. There will be times, for example, when a team takes time to build something that will save time or generate revenue, and that’s okay, because it’s a long game. And like any other client project, an internal project needs ongoing effort to ensure it’s managed well.

SARAH: Absolutely. You have to revisit these assumptions, because they won’t be correct out of the gate. As soon as you publish those targets, you’ll be wrong, and if you hold them too closely, you and your team will be frustrated. Instead, frame utilization as something to discover: let’s get good baseline data, then see what it can tell us.

KATE: I really like all of this. To put one possible outcome on tracking nonbillable utilization for readers: when you do it well, it can reveal things about your ICPs and where you want to do more business that you might not otherwise see.

For example, I worked in an agency that did a lot of government work. We had great projects, it gave us our start, and we loved it. But over time, we realized we had lower-lift, higher-margin opportunities with startups, so we started phasing out most government contracts. We couldn’t have made that strategic choice without understanding our utilization metrics, and especially our nonbillable client admin time.

JIM: To that end, I find it really helpful to engage people across the agency in defining utilization goals. Put goals in front of team leaders and let them tell you what you’re missing. That learning and refinement is necessary and never perfect, but it’s absolutely worth doing, because it signals again that utilization is about running the business more effectively in service of the whole team.

That continuous learning can make teams very strategically sophisticated. A case in point: I’ve seen teams learn to calculate the opportunity cost of pursuing a particular client, then set guardrails around pursuit cost to make sure the client will be profitable. This idea, that utilization can inform decisions about your ICP and strategic plan, is an underappreciated and rarely described component of utilization.

SARAH: I love that example, and here’s another: when you understand utilization across teams, you can build in opportunities for on-the-job cross-training. If you have underutilized staff, there could be an opportunity to tap into a project they wouldn’t have seen otherwise. Use that time to expose a writer to content strategy work, or to loop a new designer into the brand strategy process. And every agency has a list of untouched to-dos: knowing staff utilization helps you see where you can knock out one of those longstanding projects.

When agency leaders push back on utilization tracking, what are they usually worried about?

SARAH: I see two common complaints all the time. One: “Time tracking is another task on my plate, and I’m busy.” Two: “Why do you need to see how I’m spending my time, or how my team spends theirs?”

JIM: Agreed. I think it happens because the executive team hasn’t communicated the benefit to everyone in a compelling way. Instead, they frame time tracking as a nuisance, or they’re patronizing about it, or they make it more complicated than necessary, measuring in 15-minute increments or by tasks, not projects. That will absolutely disrupt creative flow.

SARAH: Right. It’s easy to turn on a timer in your project management system when you start work on a project for the day. It takes a couple of clicks. It’s nonsense to try to estimate how long it took to respond to a batch of edits or send five emails. I don't want to see that, and I don't need to know. Cut that out. 

Finally, to Jim’s point, if senior management has no trust or belief in the value of utilization, it won’t go anywhere.

JIM: You know, Sarah, time-tracking initiatives often get introduced as necessary for financial or operational purposes, but framed as something done to people, not to support them. It’s essential to set the table differently: utilization goals should help everyone do their best work, happily and well.

SARAH: It's a way to protect your people by setting boundaries, rather than always putting that impetus on the people doing the work.

KATE: I’m still learning to set and keep boundaries in my work. I only learned by working with a great COO and project manager who set clear scopes and boundaries (and involved me in scoping projects too). On that team, when I hit the limit on a project, if it was good enough to ship, out it went.

JIM: Do you like that constraint? Some people respond well to time limits, but others see it as the enemy to creativity. 

KATE: Honestly, I enjoy it, in part because I came up in academia, where there’s no time-tracking or utilization awareness and people just keep putting work on your plate, saying, “Be happy. You’re in academia.” For me, overwhelm is anathema to creativity. Boundaries keep it in check.

But it’s also a fact of life that you can’t spend endless time on anything. This is true of any project, but especially creative work: the task grows to fit the space. If I have a 20-hour constraint for a lit review, I’ll make different in-the-moment decisions about each piece of the project. Twenty hours won’t give you a comprehensive lit review of most topics, but done right, it can still give you an evidence base on which to situate a novel claim. Setting time-use boundaries helps define what good looks like and what the value to the client is. That helps me put my arms around a project that could have a variety of entry points.

That said, creative work doesn’t always go to plan. When it doesn’t, that’s important information to take back to leadership, who are scoping, pricing, and selling your services. If they don’t know what it takes to do a project, they’ll lose margin, you’ll be burned out, and the client will be unhappy. Everyone loses.

SARAH: I’d add that everyone (finance, creative, managers, leadership) tends to overplay the trope that “Creatives don’t get the numbers, it’s not important to them, and they won't be on board with this.” It’s just wrong. For one thing, creative services are like any other professional service: you have to deliver the product, on time and on scope. That’s the job. But creatives have to engage with finance. They have credit cards, pay taxes, and manage monthly budgets. It’s not something they don’t or can’t understand.

KATE: Right. So many creatives hold down a corporate job to fund a side hustle as a working artist or writer, so it's not like they aren't aware of the money, or their limited time. Measuring my utilization is empowering, because it helps me make better decisions as a creative entrepreneur. 

JIM: It’s interesting, because I see two extremes teams run into with time tracking and utilization. On one hand, people claim more time than they spent. On the other hand, shadow hours go untracked because it’s hard to stay within the time frame, and people don’t want to get in trouble, so they just eat that time. Neither is ideal. 

I hate the phrase “healthy tension,” but there needs to be some here to keep utilization and scopes accurate: creative team members should be empowered to say, “This work needs more time,” but also prepared for project managers to push back. Ultimately, you want something productive to come from that conversation: revisit a process or scope, or level-set on what good looks like. Then agree together on how to move forward.

What’s the smallest, least painful way an agency can start tracking utilization, and what would it unlock in the first 90 days?

SARAH: Don’t make assumptions about utilization or start with goals. This is a time to learn, not direct. Just track time. Start by figuring out the simplest means of time-tracking that gives you meaningful data. As Jim mentioned earlier, a good rule of thumb is to track by project, not task: it’s about filling jars with the most important rocks, not pea gravel. Then let it run for 90 days, see what you get, and go from there.

And don't start by saying, “Okay, everyone, here’s our utilization plan, and everyone needs to do this and not that.” That’s too much: you’ll get pushback, it won’t be accurate, and everyone will feel micromanaged.

JIM: I agree with Sarah, and I’d add that in addition to tracking time, talk about it. 

There are lots of ways to do that, like incorporating it into weekly check-ins, but the key is to have some function leads plus a couple of executive team members look at utilization weekly and discuss what they’re learning. But just talk; don’t judge. Talk about what it does and doesn’t tell you about your business, resources, or current strategy. There’s no end date on this learning. As new strategies, types of work, or team members are added, your utilization will change. For that reason, it’s essential to build utilization awareness into day-to-day operations.

KATE: When I’ve worked in thriving, happy agencies, my direct managers touched on utilization with staff at least monthly as part of capacity planning, but they were always willing to talk about how individual projects were shaking out, too. Those managers had a genuine interest in the nuances of the work and took a non-judgmental approach to understanding its requirements and constraints. It also gave me the chance to flag scoping changes or team member needs to someone who could directly influence the outcome. That’s priceless for creative staff.

JIM: Those kinds of conversations are often some of the most meaningful. You can be doing everything right on paper (nice growth, great margins, good cash flow, tracking time well), but if you aren’t talking about utilization consistently, you miss deeper insights that could drive real value or even competitive advantage.

There’s a different kind of pushback to utilization tracking in a scenario like this one: leadership doesn’t see the value of adding what feels like a layer of bureaucracy when things are working well. It can be difficult to get leadership over that hurdle, even if they intuitively realize a more granular view of utilization might benefit them. I see it all the time: there’s a reluctance to run the business in a more data-driven way if the leadership team feels their instincts are sufficient.

To get that buy-in, I ask them to humor me for a few weeks, give me their utilization data, and let me run some comparisons. When they see, “Oh, hey, content is regularly busier than digital, training is only 40% utilized, graphic design sees these seasonal surges,” or whatever it might be, leaders typically want to learn more. It’s absolutely critical if you know you’re going to see growth or decline. If historical data shows that teams that haven’t been busy probably won’t continue to be, you have options: make cuts, or do some significant biz dev to get them back to work. 

Utilization gives companies a tighter level of control over their business year to year—and while you can't plan for everything, you can plan for more than you think. Good utilization data is the ground-floor for every strategic choice that follows.


Level Agencies is a content stream devoted to finance for creative businesses, from marketing and PR to experience design to architecture. If you sell creative services, you belong here.

Keep learning with Level—subscribe to our newsletter, and get agency finance insights direct to your inbox monthly.  

Next
Next

Clean Up Operations, 101